Log in

View Full Version : Chavez - your thoughts?



PPLE
01-31-2007, 10:32 AM
Chavez Tightens Grip on Venezuela
http://www.npr.org/templates/story/stor ... Id=7092786 (http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=7092786)
Listen to this via above link

by Juan Forero

Morning Edition, January 31, 2007 · Venezuelan President Hugo Chavez has started his third presidential term — one that has him serving until 2013 — with a flurry of policy moves that have shaken his opponents and mesmerized his supporters.

Chavez wants the constitution reformed so he can run indefinitely. On Wednesday, the National Assemby is expected to give Chavez the power to push through new laws to accelerate what he calls "21st-century socialism."

The El Leon cafe in Caracas sits near the Spanish consulate in Venezuelan capital. Every morning, a long line forms outside — a line of Venezuelans scrambling to leave their country.

"I'm concerned about the destiny of the situation in Venezuela," says Paula Cadenas, who was in the line recently. "The obsession about taking this turn to the left — but to a very radical left side — I think it's tending to exclude the other that doesn't think as you do."

In a series of announcements in recent weeks, Chavez has promised to install a socialist state and redistribute Venezuela's oil-generated wealth.

It will be far from communism, which is what his critics claim he wants. But 21st-century socialism does mean nationalizing utilities. It means more state control of the oil sector. And the National Assembly is about to give the president the power to enact economic laws by decree for 18 months.

A shoe factory in Caracas' poor west end is an example of what Chavez wants. Here, 80 workers make one kind of shoe. It's black and nondescript. Thousands of pairs are exported to Cuba, Venezuela's closest ally.

This factory, run by state-organized cooperatives, is the new Venezuela. Gustavo Zuniga is among the "leaders." There is no manager.

"We went from being instruments of capitalism to being the owners of a company that produces goods for a community," Zuniga says. "We are conscious that this is the economy that can save the world."

In a highly polarized country, the changes are captivating to Paula Cadenas's cousin, Joanna Cadenas. She is a teacher at the state's Bolivarian University. She always dreamed of a government that would take care of its people.

Sitting in a noisy shopping mall, sipping a beer, she heralded the government's so-called missions: health, education and nutrition programs bankrolled by oil dollars.

Venezuela seems caught between two worlds. One is capitalist, where oil is king. But tugging the other way is Chavez's so-called Bolivarian Revolution.

Chavez's larger-than-life persona permeates it all. His face is plastered on posters. His marathon speeches dominate the airwaves.

Chavez supporters, such as Ivan Camejo, love the persona. He sells Chavez dolls on the main plaza.

"It's a Chavez doll, a doll that talks," Camejo says. "It's cool. I'm selling a lot. I support him a lot."

Yet there are plenty of Venezuelans who believe too much power is being concentrated in one man's hands. Demetrio Boersner is a prominent leftist academic.

"He has gone ahead too fast and a lot of people are worried, not only in the Venezuelan opposition and Venezuelans at large — neutral Venezuelans — but also within his own political coalition," Boersner says.

Boersner points to Chavez's controversial dictate to fold all pro-Chavez political parties in the National Assembly into his newly created United Socialist Party.

With the president so strong, the opposition movement might seem broken. But some leaders remain optimistic. That's because there are battles on the horizon they say will mobilize people.

One involves schools.

Chavez has talked about injecting more of the government's Bolivarian ideology into schools. At a public school in Chacao, a decidedly anti-Chavez district of Caracas, the plans do not go down well.

Julio Borges, a prominent opposition leader, promises a fight.

"For me, it's very clear that Venezuelans support President Chavez," Borges says. "That doesn't mean that they want to give him power for ever and ever in the future."

For now, everyone agrees the revolution is moving forward — and fast.

PPLE
01-31-2007, 10:34 AM
Venezuela’s promising future

Local councils – Units of Popular Power – are being set up in the hope that their members, and the small groups they represent, will take responsibility for changing their lives.

By Renaud Lambert

JUAN Guerra, a lorry driver from Zulia state, knew that he looked out of place in an office in his dirty jeans and three-day beard. But he had spent a week crossing Venezuela and he would not be intimidated by a civil servant from the national assembly. He slammed his fist on the table and said: “No, we are not asking, we are demanding that the comrade deputy transmit our complaint to the citizen president.”

Juan and his colleague Jhonny Plogar represent 700 lorry drivers. In 2000 they filed a complaint against their employers, the coal haulage companies Cootransmapa, Coozugavol and Coomaxdi. According to the plaintiffs, the companies “misused their cooperative status to benefit from tax exemptions and state contracts”. Over the past five years the two men have been shunted from office to office and Jhonny has a bulging file of copies of letters written to ministries, town halls, the state government and the president.

When Venezuela’s National Superintendence of Cooperatives (Sunacoop) finally withdrew the companies’ cooperative status, the national coal mining company continued to use their services. The Zulia state governor and presidential candidate, Manuel Rosales, who signed a decree dismantling all bodies set up during the 2002 coup, is in no hurry to put Sunacoop’s decision into effect. The bosses are using the time to get organised. Hired killers known as sicarios will soon be threatening people.

This is a common situation in Venezuela. When the two men reached the national assembly to present their case, they found a crowd of other plaintiffs with similar cases. All support Hugo Chávez, the citizen president, and all demand an end to bureaucracy and corruption. They are hostile towards a government that they consider inefficient at best, reactionary at worst. Chávez himself has said: “Our internal enemies, the most dangerous enemies of the revolution, are bureaucracy and corruption” (1).

This language has been used before to blame incompetent activists for not applying presidential policies correctly. But the “Bolivarian process” stresses popular participation as a means of transforming the state apparatus. In Venezuela it is called “the revolution in the revolution”.

Before Chávez was elected in 1998, two parties shared power for 40 years: the Venezuelan Christian Democratic party (Copei), and the social democratic party, Democratic Action (AD). They were adept at using petrodollars to deal with problems. They handed out government posts to calm social unrest but had to comply with the neoliberal ideology of the North and the need to limit public policies. The only way to offset the bloated state apparatus was to organise its inefficiency. With Venezuela’s social divisions, skilled civil servants often come from backgrounds resistant to social change, sometimes because of ignorance of the conditions in which most Venezuelans live. Gilberto Gimenez, director of the foreign minister’s private office, has said his solution was: “Diplomats will be promoted only if they spend two weeks in the barrios (working class districts).” He was smiling when he said it.

Few political leaders are able to take an active role in transforming the state from within. Before the foreign minister, Ali Rodriguez (2), got the job, six others had tried their hand since 1998.
Not a political party

The Fifth Republic Movement that brought Chávez to power is not a political party. After 1994 (3) it grew out of a coalition of leftwing parties and former guerrilla movements disgruntled with their leaders, who some thought settled too comfortably into the society they had struggled against. Young activists trained by AD and Copei quickly realised that the Chávez candidature would open up new ways to reach power and many joined his ranks.

In November 2001, when Chávez tried to pass 49 decrees to start social reform, Luis Miquilena, who had been responsible for bringing the Venezuelan left and Chávez together, decided the decrees were too radical. He resigned as interior minister (4) and his followers in the National Assembly followed. “We lost a legislature,” explained sociologist Edgar Figuera, “They were passing those laws on the cheap. Venezuela is still stuck in the legal framework of the Fourth Republic” (5). Until the country could train its activists, a revolutionary project was being built with tools inherited from a state devoted to perpetuating the neoliberal model.
http://mondediplo.com/2006/09/13venezuela

With thanks to Newswolfgang von Skeptic :) for pointing out this story that much informed my views of the above NPR piece I heard this morning

Mairead
01-31-2007, 10:57 AM
I bet there are a lot of people "scrambling to leave". I bet the same will be true here. And the same kind of people, too: the takers.

anaxarchos
01-31-2007, 11:34 AM
http://mrzine.monthlyreview.org/jacobo_arbenz227.jpg
Arbenz

http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/thumb/e/e5/Mossadeq.jpg/200px-Mossadeq.jpg
Mossadegh

http://redescolar.ilce.edu.mx/redescolar/act_permanentes/historia/html/11_sep_73/allende.gif
Allende

http://www.hrw.org/iff-00/images/lumumba.jpg
Lumumba

http://countrystudies.us/egypt/Nasser.jpg
Nasser

http://content.answers.com/main/content/wp/en/thumb/6/69/175px-Soekarno_Indonesia.jpg
Sukarno

http://www.afcam.org/Doc_illustration/BENBELLA/BENBELLA.jpg
BenBella

http://greeffprop.co.za/ancdocs/history/people/images/nyerere.jpg
Nyerere

http://ambabu.gn.apc.org/images/babu40.jpg
Babu

http://news.bbc.co.uk/olmedia/390000/images/_393254_gaddafi150..jpg
Gaddafi

http://www.nndb.com/people/034/000110701/hafez-al-assad-1.jpg
Assad

http://www.ahistoryofgreece.com/biography/top-papandreouA.jpg
Papandreou

http://www.bsnl.co.in/150/photogallery/images/nehru.jpg
Nehru

http://vivirlatino.com/i/dec05/chavez.jpg
Chavez

http://media3.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/photo/2006/01/11/PH2006011102213.jpg
Morales

.

PPLE
01-31-2007, 11:36 AM
Perhaps in the end the open-source culture will triumph not because cooperation is morally right or software "hoarding" is morally wrong ... but simply because the closed-source world cannot win an evolutionary arms race with open-source communities that can put orders of magnitude more skilled time into a problem. –Eric S. Raymond

On edit, this quote may seem a bit out of place, but it is that last part that is meaningful to me - just as the UPPs in Venezuela are.

I am going to try to keep this frame in mind as I work with a neighbor of mine who wants to create a neighborhood association in our struggling mixed race neighborhood that is showing early signs of rapacious gentrification - probably only to be slowed by the presence of public housing (thankfully, imo). Trouble is modest income homeowners will sell and be moved from the neighborhood, unable to afford the tax burden as all boats in the area rise...

Raphaelle
01-31-2007, 11:56 AM
Castro's legacy triumphant.

Mairead
01-31-2007, 11:56 AM
Perhaps in the end the open-source culture will triumph not because cooperation is morally right or software "hoarding" is morally wrong ... but simply because the closed-source world cannot win an evolutionary arms race with open-source communities that can put orders of magnitude more skilled time into a problem. –Eric S. Raymond

On edit, this quote may seem a bit out of place, but it is that last part that is meaninggul to me - just as the UPPs in Venezuela are.

I am going to try to keep this frame in mind as I work with a neighbor of mine who wants to create a neighborhood association in our struggling mixed race neighborhood that is showing early signs of rapacious gentrification - probably only to be slowed by the presence of public housing (thankfully, imo). Trouble is modest income homeowners will sell and be moved from the neighborhood, unable to afford the tax burden as all boats in the area rise...

Whenever anyone wants an example of socialism that works, I point out co-ops, credit unions, MCC, ...and open-source software. Oss is especially good, because it gives an example of internally-motivated socialism--people doing pro-social work for the sheer joy of creation.

Maybe you could organise the small homeowners in multiple neighborhoods to act as a bloc, demanding that the city leave established residents alone, upping the tax burden only the gentrifiers?

blindpig
01-31-2007, 12:21 PM
"You have to break some eggs to make an omelet." Robespierre

Some might call it a slippery slope, I call it evolution.

PPLE
01-31-2007, 12:24 PM
"You have to break some eggs to make an omelet." Robespierre

Some might call it a slippery slope, I call it evolution.

I think the thing is that we fail to drop our own mental horse blinders in appraising his decisions. The role should be smashed. Absent 50 years of American meddling, I rather doubt Chavez will find the same need to be ensconced as 'leader' in the way Castro has.